Black Holes
What happens inside a black hole?
We know black holes exist. We don't know what happens at the center, or whether information that falls in is truly lost. These theories tackle what's going on inside.
Families are sorted by how well supported they are, then by when they were first proposed. In each family the lead variant comes first.
Hawking Radiation
Hawking proved in 1974 that black holes radiate. The result has been theoretically robust for half a century: every quantum-gravity program reproduces it. No astrophysical observation has yet confirmed it directly.
Basis: theoretical
Lab analogues reproduce the wave physics at a horizon, but no radiation from an astrophysical black hole has been detected.
4 variants, since 1974
- Hawking Radiation (Original)1974 and 1975Lead variant
- Analog Hawking Radiation and Trans-Planckian Concerns1981 and 1991 and 2016
Singularity Alternatives
Five proposals for what replaces the infinite-density point at the center of a black hole. Regular metrics, gravastars, fuzzballs, quantum bounces, and the violent inner structure of rotating black holes. No observational test has yet discriminated among them.
Basis: theoretical
Current images and gravitational waves cannot see inside a horizon, and claimed echo signals were not confirmed.
6 variants, since 1968
- Regular Black Holes (Bardeen-Hayward)1968 and 2006Lead variant
- Quantum Bounce2000 and 2006 and 2020
- Gravastars2001 and 2004
- Fuzzballs (Geometric Replacement)2005 and 2022
- Planck Stars2014
Black Hole Information Paradox
Five proposals for how information escapes a black hole. The 2019 Page curve calculations show unitarity can be recovered in simplified models of semiclassical gravity, but the question of what an infalling observer experiences at the horizon locally is still open.
Basis: theoretical
Calculations since 2019 in simplified models show information can escape, but the mechanism in real black holes is open.
7 variants, since 1976
- Lead variant
- Page Curve, Islands and Replica Wormholes1993 and 2019
- Fuzzballs2005
- Firewall Paradox2013
- ER = EPR2013
- Soft Hair2016
- Historical