Before the Universe
What lies outside our space and time?
We don't know what, if anything, existed before the Big Bang. These are the serious proposals, each with a different answer to whether "before" even means anything.
Families are sorted by how well supported they are, then by when they were first proposed. In each family the lead variant comes first.
Mathematical & Structural
Reality is fundamentally mathematical or timeless. "Before" is not a meaningful question.
Basis: theoretical
Both positions are partly philosophical, and neither has yet produced a prediction that an observation could check.
2 variants, since 1957
- Mathematical Universe (Level IV)1998 and 2007Lead variant
Black Hole Genesis
Our universe was born from the collapse of a black hole in a higher-dimensional parent universe.
Basis: theoretical
A few models describe a universe born inside a black hole, and none of their predictions has been tested.
4 variants, since 1972
- Lead variant
- Popławski's Einstein-Cartan Torsion2010 and 2016
Quantum Tunneling Origin
Our universe emerged from a quantum process that does not require a pre-existing spacetime.
Basis: theoretical
The path integrals in its quantum cosmology calculations are still disputed, and no observation has tested any variant.
6 variants, since 1973
- Lead variant
- Wormhole Nucleation from Anti-de Sitter2024 and 2026
- Historical
- Historical
Eternal Inflation
Our universe is one bubble in an endlessly inflating ocean that has been spawning universes forever.
Basis: theoretical
Many inflation models that fit Planck data keep inflating somewhere, but no observation can reach the other bubbles.
3 variants, since 1980
- Lead variant
- Historical
Quantum Vacuum Mechanism
Our universe nucleated as a bubble of true vacuum inside a metastable parent vacuum.
Basis: theoretical
False-vacuum decay is established quantum field theory, but its use as the origin of our universe is untested.
1 variant, since 1980
- Lead variant
Cyclic & Bouncing Cosmologies
Our universe is one phase in an infinite sequence, what came before was a previous cycle.
Basis: theoretical
Several bounce mechanisms have been worked out, and the one claimed observational signal, Hawking points in the CMB, is disputed.
6 variants, since 1989
- Lead variant
- Simple Big Bouncevarious
Cosmological Selection
Universes reproduce through black holes, with physical laws evolving across generations by a process analogous to natural selection.
Basis: theoretical
Its one testable claim, that our constants maximise black-hole production, has no agreed test.
1 variant, since 1992
- Lead variant
Braneworld & the Bulk
Our 3D universe is a membrane floating in a higher-dimensional bulk that always existed.
Basis: theoretical
String-inspired models motivate it, and LHC searches have found no sign of extra dimensions.
2 variants, since 1998
- Randall-Sundrum1999Lead variant
Alternatives to Inflation
Theories that solve the horizon and flatness problems without a period of cosmic inflation.
Basis: theoretical
The variant's CMB polarization predictions have not yet been tested against inflation's.
1 variant, since 1999
- Lead variant
Time-Symmetric Cosmologies
The Big Bang is not a beginning but a midpoint, with time flowing in two directions from it.
Basis: theoretical
Only the CPT variant's curvature prediction has been compared with data, which it fits without confirming.
2 variants, since 2018
- Janus Universe2018Lead variant
- Boyle-Turok CPT-Symmetric Universe2021 and 2024