The Nature of Space & Time
Is spacetime fundamental, or does it emerge from something deeper?
General relativity treats spacetime as the arena where everything happens. Quantum gravity questions whether it's fundamental at all, or whether it emerges from something deeper. Nobody knows yet.
Families are sorted by how well supported they are, then by when they were first proposed. In each family the lead variant comes first.
Loop Quantum Gravity
Spacetime is quantized. Geometry has a smallest possible area and volume, and the universe is built from a network of these atomic geometric units.
Basis: theoretical
Discrete area and volume spectra and black-hole entropy counting support it, but smooth spacetime has not been shown to emerge.
2 variants, since 1986
- Lead variant
Causal Set Theory
Spacetime is a discrete network of cause-and-effect relationships, not a smooth manifold. Order plus number equals geometry. The Sorkin program is one of the longest-running discrete-spacetime quantum-gravity research lines, with one striking quasi-empirical prediction (the magnitude of the cosmological constant).
Basis: theoretical
An order-of-magnitude estimate of the cosmological constant came before its discovery, but recovering smooth spacetime is unproven.
5 variants, since 1987
- Lead variant
- Continuum Correspondence1987 and 2013-2019
- Quantum Dynamics and the BDG Action2010 and 2013-2018
Emergent Spacetime & Gravity
Spacetime may not be fundamental. It could emerge from quantum entanglement or thermodynamic relations, different proposals, same starting commitment.
Basis: theoretical
Most of it comes from anti-de Sitter models, and the one observational test, of Verlinde's dark-matter claim, gives mixed results.
5 variants, since 1995
- Holographic Spacetime1997 and 2010Lead variant
- AdS/CFT Correspondence1997 and 1998
- Banks-Fischler Holographic Space-Time2001 and 2020
- Verlinde Entropic Gravity2011 and 2017
Causal Dynamical Triangulation
Build spacetime from simple geometric blocks glued along a strict arrow of cause and effect. Run the path integral on a computer. A four-dimensional universe self-organizes from the discrete data. The most computationally productive discrete-spacetime program, with concrete numerical results no other quantum-gravity approach has produced at comparable detail.
Basis: theoretical
Simulations grow a four-dimensional universe, but no continuum limit is proven and no observation tests it.
4 variants, since 1998
- Lead variant
Deformed Special Relativity
Special relativity gains a second universal constant, a Planck-scale length or energy that every observer measures the same.
Basis: theoretical
Gamma-ray burst timing has found no Planck-scale delay, ruling out the simplest linear versions.
3 variants, since 2002
- Lead variant
Hořava-Lifshitz Gravity
A power-counting renormalizable quantum gravity theory that abandons full Lorentz invariance at high energies in favor of anisotropic scaling between space and time.
Basis: theoretical
The theory is renormalizable at high energy, but strong-coupling problems remain and observations only set limits.
3 variants, since 2009
- Lead variant
- Consistent Extension (BPS)2009 and 2011