Chapter 03 · The Nature of Space and Time
The Nature of Space & Time
Is spacetime fundamental, or does it emerge from something deeper?
General relativity treats spacetime as the arena where everything happens. Quantum gravity questions whether it's fundamental at all, or whether it emerges from something deeper. Nobody knows yet.
Families (5)
- FrontierLoop Quantum GravitySpacetime is quantized. Geometry has a smallest possible area and volume, and the universe is built from a network of these atomic geometric units.2 variants2 votes
- FrontierCausal Set TheorySpacetime is a discrete network of cause-and-effect relationships, not a smooth manifold. Order plus number equals geometry. The Sorkin program is one of the longest-running discrete-spacetime quantum-gravity research lines, with one striking quasi-empirical prediction (the magnitude of the cosmological constant).5 variants1 vote
- FrontierEmergent Spacetime & GravitySpacetime may not be fundamental. It could emerge from quantum entanglement, thermodynamic relations, or a discrete causal order, different proposals, same starting commitment.5 variants1 vote
- FrontierCausal Dynamical TriangulationBuild spacetime from simple geometric blocks glued along a strict arrow of cause and effect. Run the path integral on a computer. A four-dimensional universe self-organizes from the discrete data. The most computationally productive discrete-spacetime program, with concrete numerical results no other quantum-gravity approach has produced at comparable detail.4 variants
- FrontierHořava-Lifshitz GravityA power-counting renormalizable quantum gravity theory that abandons full Lorentz invariance at high energies in favor of anisotropic scaling between space and time.3 variants
Bridged from other chapters (6)
These variants live in their own chapters but also answer this chapter's question.
Ch.06Black Hole Information ParadoxFrontier
Black Hole Complementarity
Observations from outside and from inside the event horizon are both valid, but no single observer can compare them. The contradiction is allowed because the two pictures are observationally incompatible by construction.
→
Ch.01Mathematical & StructuralSpeculative
Mathematical Universe (Level IV)
Every mathematically consistent structure exists physically. Ours is just one.
→
Ch.01Braneworld & the BulkSpeculative
Randall-Sundrum
A 5D warped Anti-de-Sitter bulk solves the hierarchy problem via exponential warping.
→
Ch.06Hawking RadiationStrongly supported
Page Curve and Replica Wormholes
If unitarity holds, the entropy of the Hawking radiation must follow a specific curve over time. Don Page derived the curve from quantum mechanics in 1993; the 2019 replica-wormhole calculations finally reproduced it from semiclassical gravity.
→
Ch.04String TheoryFrontier
M-Theory
The five seemingly distinct 10D superstring theories are different limits of one deeper 11-dimensional theory. Strings are not fundamental on their own; branes of various dimensions are equally fundamental.
→
Ch.06Black Hole Information ParadoxFrontier
ER = EPR
Maldacena and Susskind's 2013 conjecture that every entangled pair of particles is connected by a wormhole. Applied to the firewall paradox, the entanglement between late Hawking radiation and the interior IS the geometric continuation across the horizon, so no firewall is needed.
→
Ch. 3 · what readers find most compelling, 4 votes cast
Early days, votes still coming in.
4 votes cast
- ★ 01Emergent Spacetime & Gravity1vote
- 02Loop Quantum Gravity1vote
- 03Loop Quantum Gravity1vote
- 04Causal Set Theory1vote
- 05Emergent Spacetime & Gravity0votes