Compare · Black Holes

Island Formula and Quantum Extremal Surfaces vs Page Curve and Replica Wormholes

← Back to Island Formula and Quantum Extremal Surfaces

Hawking Radiation· within family

	Island Formula and Quantum Extremal Surfaces Strongly supported	Page Curve and Replica Wormholes Strongly supported
Proposed	2019	1993 / 2019
Key figures	Geoffrey Penington, Ahmed Almheiri, Netta Engelhardt, Donald Marolf, Henry Maxfield	Don Page, Geoffrey Penington, Ahmed Almheiri, Netta Engelhardt, Donald Marolf, Henry Maxfield
In one sentence	The Island Formula is the specific calculational prescription that lets gravity reproduce the Page curve for Hawking radiation. Independently developed in two 2019 papers, by Penington and by Almheiri-Engelhardt-Marolf-Maxfield, it extends the Engelhardt-Wall quantum extremal surface rule to permit disconnected contributions, the islands. Past the Page time the dominant island absorbs the black hole interior into the radiation's entanglement wedge, which forces the radiation entropy back down along the unitary Page trajectory.	If quantum mechanics is preserved when a black hole radiates away, the entropy of the Hawking radiation has to follow a specific shape over time: it rises while the black hole is big, peaks around the moment half the mass has been radiated (the Page time), then comes back down. Don Page proved this in 1993. For 26 years no one could derive the curve from semiclassical gravity. The 2019 replica-wormhole calculations finally reproduced it, using contributions to the gravitational path integral from spacetime geometries that include wormholes.
Predictions	The entropy of any region containing Hawking radiation past the Page time is computed by a prescription that includes islands, and that prescription must reproduce the exact Page-curve trajectory; this can be checked in solvable lower-dimensional gravity models where the curve is calculable from start to finish The black hole interior is encoded in the late-time Hawking radiation in a specific, calculable sense, via entanglement wedge reconstruction applied to the radiation region The formula reduces to the Engelhardt-Wall prescription before the Page time and produces the Page-curve drop after it, with the transition driven by which surface dominates the extremization The same prescription applies to any quantum system coupled to gravity, not just to evaporating black holes; the construction is testable in lower-dimensional gravity models like 2D Jackiw-Teitelboim	The von Neumann entropy of the Hawking radiation follows the Page curve: it grows linearly with radiated mass past the start, peaks at the Page time (when half the initial mass has evaporated), then decreases linearly back to zero as the black hole disappears Past the Page time the calculation is dominated by a new geometry, a replica wormhole that connects copies of the spacetime, rather than the standard Hawking geometry; this switch in which geometry matters most is what forces the entropy back down The radiation past the Page time encodes the black hole interior in a precise (entanglement-wedge-reconstruction) sense, with the encoding becoming explicit through the replica-wormhole calculation Information is recoverable from the radiation in principle, but the effort required grows exponentially with the black hole's initial size, making the recovery effectively impossible in practice (the Harlow-Hayden 2013 argument)
Where it breaks	The island prescription has been derived rigorously only in specific toy models; whether it extends to physically realistic four-dimensional evaporating black holes in our universe is conjectured but not yet proved The formula is a prescription for computing the entropy, not a mechanism explaining what physical degrees of freedom encode the interior; the question of what carries information out remains debated The construction relies on entanglement wedge reconstruction in AdS/CFT settings; the carry-over to asymptotically flat space, which is the actual setting of black hole evaporation in our universe, involves additional technical steps that are still being worked out Some authors interpret the island contribution as an artifact of summing over topologies in the gravitational path integral, with no unambiguous local physical interpretation; whether the islands have a direct interpretation as physical interior regions is contested	The replica-wormhole derivations are explicit only in specific toy models (2D JT gravity, AdS settings); whether the construction extends to realistic 4D evaporating black holes in our universe is conjectured but not proved The construction recovers the von Neumann entropy curve but does not directly tell you what an infalling observer experiences at the horizon locally; that remains a separate question (the BHIP family covers it) Some authors (Marolf, Bousso, and collaborators in various papers) argue the replica-wormhole results are best interpreted as a reframing of the information paradox rather than its resolution; the original physical question about local horizon physics is partially separate from the von Neumann entropy story The path-integral derivations involve choices (how to define entropy, which contour to integrate over, how to interpret summing over topologies) that are technically debated; not all authors agree the calculation is fully under control
Key unresolved problem	The realistic-black-hole problem: the island prescription has only been derived inside special AdS/CFT model universes, and extending it cleanly to ordinary four-dimensional black holes like the ones we actually observe remains unsolved.	The toy-model problem: the replica-wormhole derivation works only in simplified model universes, and no one has shown it carries over to the realistic four-dimensional black holes that actually evaporate in our universe.
Reader vote	No votes yet	No votes yet

Island Formula and Quantum Extremal Surfaces

2019 · Strongly supported

Page Curve and Replica Wormholes

1993 / 2019 · Strongly supported

Proposed

2019

1993 / 2019

Key figures

Geoffrey Penington, Ahmed Almheiri, Netta Engelhardt, Donald Marolf, Henry Maxfield

Don Page, Geoffrey Penington, Ahmed Almheiri, Netta Engelhardt, Donald Marolf, Henry Maxfield

In one sentence

The Island Formula is the specific calculational prescription that lets gravity reproduce the Page curve for Hawking radiation. Independently developed in two 2019 papers, by Penington and by Almheiri-Engelhardt-Marolf-Maxfield, it extends the Engelhardt-Wall quantum extremal surface rule to permit disconnected contributions, the islands. Past the Page time the dominant island absorbs the black hole interior into the radiation's entanglement wedge, which forces the radiation entropy back down along the unitary Page trajectory.

If quantum mechanics is preserved when a black hole radiates away, the entropy of the Hawking radiation has to follow a specific shape over time: it rises while the black hole is big, peaks around the moment half the mass has been radiated (the Page time), then comes back down. Don Page proved this in 1993. For 26 years no one could derive the curve from semiclassical gravity. The 2019 replica-wormhole calculations finally reproduced it, using contributions to the gravitational path integral from spacetime geometries that include wormholes.

Predictions

The entropy of any region containing Hawking radiation past the Page time is computed by a prescription that includes islands, and that prescription must reproduce the exact Page-curve trajectory; this can be checked in solvable lower-dimensional gravity models where the curve is calculable from start to finish
The black hole interior is encoded in the late-time Hawking radiation in a specific, calculable sense, via entanglement wedge reconstruction applied to the radiation region
The formula reduces to the Engelhardt-Wall prescription before the Page time and produces the Page-curve drop after it, with the transition driven by which surface dominates the extremization
The same prescription applies to any quantum system coupled to gravity, not just to evaporating black holes; the construction is testable in lower-dimensional gravity models like 2D Jackiw-Teitelboim

The von Neumann entropy of the Hawking radiation follows the Page curve: it grows linearly with radiated mass past the start, peaks at the Page time (when half the initial mass has evaporated), then decreases linearly back to zero as the black hole disappears
Past the Page time the calculation is dominated by a new geometry, a replica wormhole that connects copies of the spacetime, rather than the standard Hawking geometry; this switch in which geometry matters most is what forces the entropy back down
The radiation past the Page time encodes the black hole interior in a precise (entanglement-wedge-reconstruction) sense, with the encoding becoming explicit through the replica-wormhole calculation
Information is recoverable from the radiation in principle, but the effort required grows exponentially with the black hole's initial size, making the recovery effectively impossible in practice (the Harlow-Hayden 2013 argument)

Where it breaks

The island prescription has been derived rigorously only in specific toy models; whether it extends to physically realistic four-dimensional evaporating black holes in our universe is conjectured but not yet proved
The formula is a prescription for computing the entropy, not a mechanism explaining what physical degrees of freedom encode the interior; the question of what carries information out remains debated
The construction relies on entanglement wedge reconstruction in AdS/CFT settings; the carry-over to asymptotically flat space, which is the actual setting of black hole evaporation in our universe, involves additional technical steps that are still being worked out
Some authors interpret the island contribution as an artifact of summing over topologies in the gravitational path integral, with no unambiguous local physical interpretation; whether the islands have a direct interpretation as physical interior regions is contested

The replica-wormhole derivations are explicit only in specific toy models (2D JT gravity, AdS settings); whether the construction extends to realistic 4D evaporating black holes in our universe is conjectured but not proved
The construction recovers the von Neumann entropy curve but does not directly tell you what an infalling observer experiences at the horizon locally; that remains a separate question (the BHIP family covers it)
Some authors (Marolf, Bousso, and collaborators in various papers) argue the replica-wormhole results are best interpreted as a reframing of the information paradox rather than its resolution; the original physical question about local horizon physics is partially separate from the von Neumann entropy story
The path-integral derivations involve choices (how to define entropy, which contour to integrate over, how to interpret summing over topologies) that are technically debated; not all authors agree the calculation is fully under control

Key unresolved problem

The realistic-black-hole problem: the island prescription has only been derived inside special AdS/CFT model universes, and extending it cleanly to ordinary four-dimensional black holes like the ones we actually observe remains unsolved.

The toy-model problem: the replica-wormhole derivation works only in simplified model universes, and no one has shown it carries over to the realistic four-dimensional black holes that actually evaporate in our universe.

Reader vote

No votes yet