Island Formula and Quantum Extremal Surfaces
A prescription for computing the entropy of Hawking radiation by extremizing a generalized surface that can include disconnected pieces of the bulk, the 'islands.' Past the Page time the dominant island captures the black hole interior, which is why the radiation's entropy comes back down.
Placeholder for a 3D visualisation of Hawking Radiation. The interactive scene will land in Phase 3. In 1974 Hawking applied quantum mechanics to the spacetime just outside a black hole's event horizon and derived a remarkable consequence: black holes emit a steady stream of particles, as if they were hot bodies with a precise temperature inversely proportional to their mass. The result built on Bekenstein's 1973 entropy argument that black holes have entropy proportional to horizon area, and it pinned down the temperature that goes with that entropy. The Bekenstein-Hawking formula (entropy proportional to one quarter of the horizon area in Planck units) is now the foundation of black hole thermodynamics. Five decades of follow-up work have refined the original derivation: Don Page's 1993 result that the radiation entropy must follow a specific curve for unitarity to hold, the 2019 replica-wormhole calculations that finally reproduced that curve from semiclassical gravity, Jeff Steinhauer's 2016 and 2019 Bose-Einstein condensate experiments that appear to confirm the underlying mathematics in laboratory analogs, and modifications from each candidate quantum-gravity program. Direct astrophysical observation of Hawking radiation remains elusive: temperatures for astrophysical black holes are nanokelvin-scale, far below background, and fifty years of searches for primordial black holes evaporating today have set tight upper limits without a detection.
§1 · The claim, in one sentence
The Island Formula is the specific calculational prescription that lets gravity reproduce the Page curve for Hawking radiation. Independently developed in two 2019 papers, by Penington and by Almheiri-Engelhardt-Marolf-Maxfield, it extends the Engelhardt-Wall quantum extremal surface rule to permit disconnected contributions, the islands. Past the Page time the dominant island absorbs the black hole interior into the radiation's entanglement wedge, which forces the radiation entropy back down along the unitary Page trajectory.
§2 · Why it might be true
The 1993 Page result said that if quantum mechanics is preserved during black hole evaporation, the radiation entropy must follow a specific curve. The 2019 island formula is the rule that lets you compute that entropy from semiclassical gravity directly. Pick a region you want the entropy of, say the Hawking radiation collected far from the hole. Search over all candidate surfaces, including ones that wrap around disconnected pieces of the bulk. For each candidate, compute the generalized entropy, the area divided by four times Newton's constant plus the von Neumann entropy of quantum fields outside the surface. The true entropy is the minimum of the extremized values.
Before the Page time the dominant surface is the trivial one near the horizon, and the island prescription reduces to Engelhardt-Wall 2015. Past the Page time a new surface dominates: one whose extremal configuration includes a disconnected region inside the black hole. That interior region is the island. Including it brings the entropy back down, exactly tracking the Page curve. The formula is the same in both regimes; only the dominant solution changes.
Penington in arXiv:1905.08255 derived the formula from quantum information considerations in AdS/CFT, focusing on entanglement wedge reconstruction. Almheiri, Engelhardt, Marolf and Maxfield in arXiv:1905.08762 derived it as a generalization of the quantum extremal surface prescription applied to evaporating black holes. The two derivations appeared within weeks of each other and agree on the prescription. Almheiri-Hartman-Maldacena-Shaghoulian-Tajdini in arXiv:1911.12333 supplied the underlying gravitational-path-integral mechanism via replica wormholes. The sibling Page Curve and Replica Wormholes variant covers the entropy result and the path-integral mechanism; this variant covers the prescription itself.
The family stance
Black holes are not black. Hawking's 1974 derivation showed they emit thermal radiation at a temperature set inversely by their mass, and that they have entropy proportional to their horizon area. Every candidate theory of quantum gravity reproduces this leading-order result. The completeness questions, what happens to the radiation past the Page time (unitarity), what the radiation does to the geometry it leaves behind (backreaction), and what cuts off the high-energy modes near the horizon (trans-Planckian), have been substantially clarified since 2019 but are not fully closed. Direct astrophysical observation is theoretically possible but practically inaccessible with current and foreseeable instruments.
§2.5 · Evidence
- Two independent 2019 derivations, Penington as a single author and AEMM as a four-author group, reached the same prescription from different starting points within weeks of each other
- The formula has been verified to reproduce the Page curve in multiple toy gravity models including 2D Jackiw-Teitelboim, asymptotically anti-de Sitter settings, and the RST model
- Almheiri-Hartman-Maldacena-Shaghoulian-Tajdini 2019 supplied the underlying gravitational path integral mechanism via replica wormholes, anchoring the prescription in a concrete calculational technique
- The construction reproduces previously-known holographic entropy results, Ryu-Takayanagi 2006, Hubeny-Rangamani-Takayanagi 2007, and Engelhardt-Wall 2015, as the trivial-island special case, extending the existing machinery rather than replacing it
§3 · What you'd need to test it
- The entropy of any region containing Hawking radiation past the Page time is given by extremizing the generalized entropy over a class of surfaces that permit island contributions
- The black hole interior is encoded in the late-time Hawking radiation in a specific, calculable sense, via entanglement wedge reconstruction applied to the radiation region
- The formula reduces to the Engelhardt-Wall prescription before the Page time and produces the Page-curve drop after it, with the transition driven by which surface dominates the extremization
- The same prescription applies to any quantum system coupled to gravity, not just to evaporating black holes; the construction is testable in lower-dimensional gravity models like 2D Jackiw-Teitelboim
§4 · Where it breaks
- The island prescription has been derived rigorously only in specific toy models; whether it extends to physically realistic four-dimensional evaporating black holes in our universe is conjectured but not yet proved
- The formula is a prescription for computing the entropy, not a mechanism explaining what physical degrees of freedom encode the interior; the question of what carries information out remains debated
- The construction relies on entanglement wedge reconstruction in AdS/CFT settings; the carry-over to asymptotically flat space, which is the actual setting of black hole evaporation in our universe, involves additional technical steps that are still being worked out
- Some authors interpret the island contribution as an artifact of summing over topologies in the gravitational path integral, with no unambiguous local physical interpretation; whether the islands have a direct interpretation as physical interior regions is contested
Go deeper
The Engelhardt-Wall 2015 quantum extremal surface prescription extends the Ryu-Takayanagi formula by extremizing the generalized entropy, area plus bulk matter entropy outside the surface, rather than just the area. The island formula extends Engelhardt-Wall further by allowing the extremization domain to include disconnected surface components, the islands. Before the Page time the dominant solution has no island; past it the dominant solution has one.
For a 2D Jackiw-Teitelboim black hole evaporating into a flat-space bath, the island formula gives an explicit closed-form Page curve. Penington's 2019 paper worked this case in detail. AEMM 2019 worked similar models in higher dimensions with similar results. AHMST 2019 derived the same Page curve by computing the gravitational path integral with replica wormholes contributing the dominant saddle past the Page time.
The connection to the Black Hole Information Paradox family's ER=EPR variant is direct: replica wormholes are the ER=EPR mechanism realized in the path integral. The island formula is the entropy prescription; the ER=EPR variant covers the geometric story of why the entropy works out this way. Two views of the same physics. The Page Curve variant in this same family covers the entropy trajectory; this variant covers the prescription that produces it.
The construction is currently considered the strongest available evidence for unitarity in black hole evaporation from semiclassical gravity. Whether it resolves the information paradox in full or reframes it remains a live editorial question. The formula tells you the entropy is unitary; it does not directly tell you what an infalling observer experiences at the horizon locally. That question stays open.
Variants in this family
▸§5 · Who built it, and when(4 sources, 4 established)
- EstablishedPenington (2020). Entanglement Wedge Reconstruction and the Information Paradox. JHEP 09, 002
- EstablishedAlmheiri, Engelhardt, Marolf & Maxfield (2019). The entropy of bulk quantum fields and the entanglement wedge of an evaporating black hole. JHEP 12, 063
- EstablishedAlmheiri, Hartman, Maldacena, Shaghoulian & Tajdini (2020). Replica Wormholes and the Entropy of Hawking Radiation. JHEP 05, 013
- EstablishedEngelhardt & Wall (2015). Quantum Extremal Surfaces: Holographic Entanglement Entropy beyond the Classical Regime. JHEP 01, 073
Up next
Spotted an error? Have a source to add?
Prefer email?
You can also send a prefilled email with the variant URL already filled in.