Maybe the universe is just a long-lived quantum fluctuation. Net energy: zero.
Tryon Vacuum Fluctuation
The universe as a zero-energy quantum fluctuation, the historical first proposal.
Looping ambient scene for Quantum Tunneling Origin. This family represents the 'null answer' to the chapter question: that there was no spacetime, no fields, no 'before' in any coherent sense. Apply quantum mechanics to the origin of the universe itself. The result is a wavefunction over possible universes; ours is the one that emerged. Different variants disagree on the boundary condition.
§1 · The claim, in one sentence
Tryon's 1973 Nature paper proposed the universe is a quantum fluctuation with zero net energy, the historical precursor to all "universe from nothing" proposals.
§2 · Why it might be true
Edward Tryon, in a one-page Nature paper in 1973, made the historically first version of the "universe from nothing" argument. His insight: the total energy of the universe may be zero, because the positive energy in matter and radiation is precisely cancelled by the negative gravitational potential energy. A zero-energy event can, in principle, fluctuate from vacuum.
His remark: "Our universe is simply one of those things which happens from time to time." This was a precursor to Vilenkin's more developed 1982 framework, but lacks the formal quantum cosmology machinery.
The family stance
Either literally nothing (Vilenkin), or a state without a temporal boundary (Hartle-Hawking), or a zero-energy quantum fluctuation (Tryon). All deny that a classical "before" makes sense.
§2.5 · Evidence
- Total energy of observable universe is consistent with zero
- Historically opened the question
§3 · What you'd need to test it
- Total energy of universe ~ 0
- Universes can spontaneously fluctuate from vacuum
§4 · Where it breaks
- Tryon's proposal still presupposes a quantum vacuum and laws, not truly nothing
- Vilenkin (1982) provides the rigorous framework Tryon lacked
Go deeper
Tryon's argument relied on the cosmological observation that, in standard FRW cosmology, the total energy of a closed universe is exactly zero, the positive rest-mass and kinetic energies of matter are precisely balanced by the negative gravitational binding energy. He framed this as license for the universe to be a quantum fluctuation of energy ΔE × Δt ~ ℏ, with ΔE ≈ 0 allowing arbitrarily large Δt.
The proposal pre-dates the Wheeler-DeWitt equation formalism of quantum cosmology. Vilenkin's 1982 paper built on Tryon's insight but with a proper wavefunction-of-the-universe framework.
▸§5 · Who built it, and when(1 source, 1 established)
Variants in this family
Compare variantsUp next
Spotted an error? Have a source to add?
Prefer email?
You can also send a prefilled email with the variant URL already filled in.