Skip to content
Cosmos Explorer

Eternal Inflation, two variants compared

Our universe is one bubble in an endlessly inflating ocean that has been spawning universes forever.

Speculative

Basis: theoretical

Many inflation models that fit Planck data keep inflating somewhere, but no observation can reach the other bubbles.

In one line

Variant A
String theory permits a vast forest of universes. We landed in one of them.
Variant B
The first inflation model. Worked, except it never stopped, in the wrong way.

The claim

Variant A
String theory permits ~10⁵⁰⁰ different vacuum states. Each bubble lands in a different one.
Variant B
The original proposal: a phase transition drove exponential expansion.

What would test it

Variant A

3 predictions, first shown

Vast number of possible vacuum states

All 3
Variant B

4 predictions, first shown

Exponential expansion in the very early universe

All 4

Where it breaks

Variant A

3 objections, first shown

No direct evidence of other vacua

All 3
Variant B

2 objections, first shown

Original "old inflation" had the graceful exit problem

All 2

Shared by both

3 shared objections, first shown

No way to verify other bubbles exist, causally disconnected

All 3

Key unresolved problem

Variant A
A map you cannot read: no one has found our own universe's physics among the landscape's roughly 10^500 possible vacua or proven the whole construction holds together, so it stays a vast count of possibilities rather than a theory that points to ours.
Variant B
The graceful-exit problem: a first-order phase transition never reheats the universe, because the true-vacuum bubbles expand too fast to collide and thermalise, so there is no smooth handoff to a hot Big Bang.

Proposed

Variant A

2003

Leonard Susskind, Raphael Bousso, Joseph Polchinski

Variant B

1980

Alan Guth

Sources

Variant A

5, all established

5,632 INSPIRE citations, from 4 of 5 sources

Variant B

2, all established

415 INSPIRE citations, from 1 of 2 sources

Readers

Variant A

No votes yet

Variant B

No votes yet