Eternal Inflation, two variants comparedCompare two Eternal Inflation variants
Our universe is one bubble in an endlessly inflating ocean that has been spawning universes forever.
Speculative
Basis: theoretical
Many inflation models that fit Planck data keep inflating somewhere, but no observation can reach the other bubbles.
Speculative Open the variant page | Historical Open the variant page | |
|---|---|---|
| Proposed | 2003 Leonard Susskind, Raphael Bousso, Joseph Polchinski | 1980 Alan Guth |
| In one line | String theory permits a vast forest of universes. We landed in one of them. | The first inflation model. Worked, except it never stopped, in the wrong way. |
| The claim | String theory permits ~10⁵⁰⁰ different vacuum states. Each bubble lands in a different one. | The original proposal: a phase transition drove exponential expansion. |
| What would test it | 3 predictions, first shown Vast number of possible vacuum states All 3 | 4 predictions, first shown Exponential expansion in the very early universe All 4 |
| Where it breaks | 3 objections, first shown No direct evidence of other vacua All 3 | 2 objections, first shown Original "old inflation" had the graceful exit problem All 2 |
| Shared by both | 3 shared objections, first shown No way to verify other bubbles exist, causally disconnected All 3 | |
| Key unresolved problem | A map you cannot read: no one has found our own universe's physics among the landscape's roughly 10^500 possible vacua or proven the whole construction holds together, so it stays a vast count of possibilities rather than a theory that points to ours. | The graceful-exit problem: a first-order phase transition never reheats the universe, because the true-vacuum bubbles expand too fast to collide and thermalise, so there is no smooth handoff to a hot Big Bang. |
| Sources | 5, all established 5,632 INSPIRE citations, from 4 of 5 sources | 2, all established 415 INSPIRE citations, from 1 of 2 sources |
| Readers | No votes yet | No votes yet |
In one line
The claim
What would test it
Where it breaks
Shared by both
Key unresolved problem
Proposed
2003
Leonard Susskind, Raphael Bousso, Joseph Polchinski
1980
Alan Guth
Sources
5, all established
5,632 INSPIRE citations, from 4 of 5 sources
2, all established
415 INSPIRE citations, from 1 of 2 sources
Readers
No votes yet
No votes yet