Skip to content
Cosmos Explorer

String Theory, two variants compared

Particles as vibrating strings in 10 or 11 dimensions, with five mathematically consistent superstring theories unified by an 11D parent. Dominant unification candidate for four decades; the empirical contact problem and the landscape problem remain open.

Frontier

Basis: theoretical

Anomaly cancellation, black-hole entropy counting and dualities support it, but no prediction distinctive to string theory has been confirmed.

In one line

Variant A
Curl the six extra dimensions in a careful way. The choice fixes which particles exist.
Variant B
Five rival string theories. All five are different angles on one deeper theory.

The claim

Variant A
String theory's historical 'derive particle physics from geometry' program. Heterotic strings carry E8 x E8 gauge symmetry; six extra dimensions curl up into a Calabi-Yau manifold whose geometry sets the 4D spectrum.
Variant B
The five seemingly distinct 10D superstring theories are different limits of one deeper 11-dimensional theory. Strings are not fundamental on their own; branes of various dimensions are equally fundamental.

What would test it

Variant A

4 predictions, first shown

Specific Calabi-Yau geometries plus a stable holomorphic vector bundle yield gauge groups, chiral fermion spectra, and generation counts in 4D; three-generation E6 or SU(5)-like models are constructible

All 4
Variant B

4 predictions, first shown

Strong-coupling limits of 10D string theories correspond to 11D M-theory sectors with specific brane and geometry content; explicit dualities relating Type IIA-M11, heterotic E8 x E8-M-on-S1/Z2, and others

All 4

Where it breaks

Variant A

4 objections, first shown

Vacuum non-uniqueness: the number of distinct Calabi-Yau manifolds plus vector bundle choices is large, and many produce semi-realistic spectra; no unique vacuum has been derived from first principles

All 4
Variant B

4 objections, first shown

No complete non-perturbative definition: M-theory is known patchwise via dualities and special limits (Matrix Theory in infinite-momentum frame; AdS/CFT in particular backgrounds), not via a single covariant Lagrangian or path-integral formulation

All 4

Shared by both

4 shared objections, first shown

The "is this physics?" critique charges that after four decades string theory has produced no falsifiable prediction at accessible energies that would distinguish it from quantum field theory plus general relativity. Defenders point to the Swampland Program (turning the lack of a unique vacuum into a source of consistency constraints), holographic dualities (AdS/CFT), and black-hole microstate counting as evidence of real physical structure. The field treats the critique as a serious open tension that defines its current phase, not as a settled refutation.

All 4

Key unresolved problem

Variant A
The moduli problem: the curled-up extra dimensions have many free size-and-shape settings, called moduli, and no one has pinned them to fixed values that single out our universe's particles.
Variant B
The missing definition problem: M-theory has no single complete equation, what physicists call a non-perturbative definition, so it is known only in scattered pieces glued together through special limits and dualities.

Proposed

Variant A

1985

Philip Candelas, Gary Horowitz, Andrew Strominger, Edward Witten

Variant B

1995

Edward Witten, Petr Hořava, Tom Banks, Willy Fischler, Stephen Shenker, Leonard Susskind

Sources

Variant A

3, all established

1,987 INSPIRE citations, from 2 of 3 sources

Variant B

3, all established

9,016 INSPIRE citations, across all 3 sources

Readers

Variant A

No votes yet

Variant B

No votes yet